Pulling Back the Shades – A Review

Posted by Randy Mann - April 15, 2014 - Blog, Christian Book Reviews - 11 Comments

As a pastor, I remember when the book Fifty Shades of Grey came out. While I was not at all surprised about the overall popularity of the book at a cultural level, I was surprised about the reports I was hearing of Christian women reading the book. I was similarly discouraged with the multitude of Facebook posts by Christian women declaring their excitement about the release of the Hollywood movie “Magic Mike.” While there were multiple available resources to warn men about the dangers of accessing sexually explicit and/or pornographic media, I knew of no similar resource for women.

Some might ask, “Are these kinds of “entertainment” really that big of a deal?” “Are they really inappropriate forms of leisure activity for Christian women?” “Do they really provide significant pitfalls for these women – spiritually, emotionally, relationally?” Authors Dannah Gresh and Dr. Juli Slattery respond with a resounding “yes.” In their new book, Pulling Back the Shades: Erotica, Intimacy and the Longings of a Woman’s Heart (Moody Publishers, 2014), these ladies go far beyond simply saying “Don’t read those books. Don’t watch those movies.” Far from taking a “sex is bad” position, they approach this topic from a biblical, holistic perspective, demonstrating God’s design for women – spiritually, emotionally and sexually – and how these forms of erotica hijack God’s design and affect women in spiritual, emotional and relational ways.

The authors rightly point out that erotica-type materials are not simply fiction, presenting life situations that DID NOT happen. According to these ladies, these materials are fantasy, presenting life situations that CANNOT happen. They therefore cause women to long for situations in real life that are not grounded in reality, setting themselves up for nothing but disappointment and dissatisfaction in their real-life relationship with their spouse or future spouse.

The approach in this book is biblical and straightforward; frank, but not vulgar. They address issues of sexuality that Christian women have questions about, but are often afraid to ask, either due to embarrassment, or out of fear of how another Christian woman might respond. The thing that most resonated with me as a pastor was the need for older, godly, mature Christian women being willing to talk to younger Christian women about these things, in a Titus 2 kind of way. The reality is, if these mature Christian women will not step up and address these things from a biblical perspective, there is no shortage of people and materials available to address them from a worldly perspective.

Ultimately, the authors demonstrate that these things are issues of the heart. As they put it, “The problem is not erotica – the problem is that we want to read it.” (133) Their goal is to help Christian women be both spiritually and sexually satisfied, according to God’s design for spiritual, sexual, emotional and relational fulfillment, which He provides in His design for male/female relationships within the context of marriage; marriages that are rooted and grounded in Him.

I am thankful to have a resource such as this to recommend to women. I will encourage the older women in our church to read this book so that they can then help our younger women in understanding and walking in God’s design for women – spiritually, emotionally, sexually and relationally. I am having my wife read it so that she can one day lead our daughter to understand these issues from a biblical perspective. I will also have young women who come to me for pre-marital counseling read this book in preparation for their new relationship with their husband.

In an effort to get the word out about this book, the publisher has made an additional copy of the book available for me to give away to one of my blog readers. If you would like to receive the free copy of the book, just be the first to comment on this post below. I will pass your information along to the publisher to send you the book.

(FTC disclaimer – I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for writing this unbiased review.)

(Accountability disclaimer – A friend very thoughtfully asked me, “Why are you reading a book for women with a subtitle such as this?” I was contacted by a publicist for the book who found my blog and book reviews and asked me to review it.)

 

11 comments

  • Evan Lenow says:

    This really is an important topic. Most people have historically felt a preoccupation with sex is a male issue, but women have been brought into this in part due to the sexual revolution. As a father of 3 daughters (and a son), I recognize that there are more ways that I have to work to guard their hearts.

  • Nicole Lino says:

    So glad to hear you encouraging older women to equip themselves to lead younger women in this arena. As I talk to older women, they are often shocked and unprepared or unwilling (for many reasons) to respond biblically to this heart issue that has such a stronghold on many younger women.

    • Randy Mann says:

      Nicole,
      Thank you. That is very true. I think it is, at least in part, a cultural/generational issue. I remember my grandmother talking about it being rude to say the word “pregnant” in public. So you know there was little, if any, discussion about matters of sexuality. Because the church has refused to speak biblically to this issue, our older ladies are unprepared to lead and our younger ladies and daughters are adopting grossly unbiblical views on matters of sexuality because the only counsel they are receiving is from a worldly perspective.

  • Kim Humphrey says:

    Thank you Randy for sharing this important topic and book. I look forward to getting and reading this, and the opportunity to walk with younger (and older) ladies as we seek biblical instruction on being godly women.

    • Randy Mann says:

      Kim,
      May God use you to influence a generation of younger Christian women to think biblically about these matters – in word and by example!

  • scott says:

    Hey Randy, thanks for this post. It is indeed an important topic. Unfortunately pornography comes in many forms and is taking a huge toll on both men and women. There are devastating results on the church and its leadership.

  • Lisa Laturno says:

    Great topic that needs to be addressed from the pulpit!! For both men and women. When these books were released and the movie was out, I wondered if I would hear a pastor address this “entertainment”. And I did not……..

    • Randy Mann says:

      Lisa,
      Unfortunately, we have remained silent while the world has shouted its views through every conceivable outlet. May we be bold enough to call God’s people to understand and walk in light of His great design – spiritually, physically, emotionally, sexually, and every other way.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read previous post:
Book Review – Uncovered: The Truth about Honesty and Community

When a book strikes a nerve with me, it is usually for one of three reasons: 1. I strongly agree...

Close